16 hours ago · 6 min read1289 words · Writing · hide

Fourteen years ago, Scott Alexander wrote of the Whispering Earring. It's a cautionary tale of an earring that advises you, and to which you increasingly defer as you realize its suggestions are better than you'd do otherwise. By your preferences you become very successful, but in the end there's nothing of you left. Ten days after Scott published the story, AlexNet won ImageNet 2012 by a huge margin, kicking off the deep learning revolution. The earring whispers advice as "better for you if you...", and it's always right. While AI today would have seemed like distant science fiction in 2012, it's still far from infallible. Looking ahead, I expect AI to continue getting better quickly, but I don't expect it ever gets to "always right". A Whispering Earring dynamic with AI, however, doesn't need infallibility. Instead, the AI just needs to be capable enough that you can't improve on its advice. [1] That's not where we are today. I use AI heavily, both in my professional and personal…

Commenting on Bubbles has been removed. Why? If you want to talk about this post, write to the author, use the comments on their blog if it has them, or reply with a "RE:" post on your own blog. Suggestions? feedback@bubbles.town