“I would be very happy to see all kinds of text editors adopt this.”

Speaking of cut in File Explorer, Will McGugan, creator of the writing editor Ishmael, proposes doing the same thing for text editing – that is, leaving ghost text behind: I call it “Ghost Cut”, and it works like this: pressing Ctrl+X fades the selected text and makes it inert—you can’t click on the cut text and the cursor just kind of leaps over it, but it is still present in the document. Nothing is placed in the clipboard at this point and there is nothing to undo. If you decide you don’t want to paste then hitting Escape will restore the text to its active editable state. I do not think this is a good idea. It seems like McGugan proposes somewhat arbitrary reasons that cut and paste are “broken,” and to me the proposal fails even within his own framework: for example, it still doesn’t avoid the reflow, but moves it to the other side, making paste feel unstable (the included JavaScript playground feels disorienting to use). I think it also is at odds with the editor’s own about…