“Solving a largely imaginary user goal”

On her blog, Lea Verou makes a case that each user-facing website dark-mode toggle should only ever show two options, but in a smart way. The challenge is that any dark mode toggle needs to actually accommodate three options: dark, light, and the default “whatever the system says” (which can be always dark, always light, or change with the time of day). Many toggles simply pass that complexity onto the user: I want to get something out of the way: I don’t think Verou’s article as an article is fully successful. I feel like it spends a great amount of words to explain something not entirely as complex, and even the interactive playgrounds felt slightly too rigid and altogether confusing. If you care about (interactive) explainers, it might be an interesting case study in and of itself. But I am very much much onboard with the proposal and the line of thinking it represents. Verou suggests a “smart” dual state toggle, which still allows the website to follow the system, but shoves the…