Bare Functionalism Versus Digital Computational Functionalism

In philosophy of mind, people sometimes say things like the following: If functionalism is true about consciousness, then digital computers could be conscious; all it requires is that they instantiate the right programs. And yes, most functionalists about consciousness do think that. But the claim about digital computer programs does not straightforwardly follow from functionalism alone. Today I want to clarify the issue by distinguishing three forms of functionalism: bare functionalism, computational functionalism, and digital computational functionalism. Bare Functionalism According to bare functionalism -- that is functionalism, without further commitments -- mental states are functional states. They are determined wholly by their causal relations to stimuli, behavior, and other mental states. Whatever plays the causal role of some mental state M is mental state M. Whatever plays the causal role of pain, for example, being apt to be caused by tissue damage and tissue stress and…