Conscious or Not

For as long as I remember, people have been arguing about whether machines could be intelligent or not. Many science fiction authors and fans — like myself — felt it was inevitable, only a matter of time. However there were many very smart experts who made very good arguments as to why machines would be fundamentally unable to think or be intelligent. They had high confidence that intelligence was uniquely human. While these arguments appeared sensible, the main fault on both sides of the controversy was that we lacked a good definition of intelligence. The argument was often reduced to relying on something called the Turing Test, which did not actually test for intelligence. Now in 2026, no one argues that machines could never be smart. We still don’t have a good definition of intelligence, but we have plenty of real life experiences with machines that are smarter than we are in some ways. LLMs outperform the average human in many intellectual tasks, although they fail in others. But…