The soul in the machine

One of the first things skeptics learn is to never assume that paranormal belief implies stupidity. Smart people believe questionable things all the time; intelligence is different from the ability to assess your own cognitive biases, especially when you are working outside your field of expertise. The astronomer Carl Sagan, one of 26 founders of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry hinted at this in saying that the more you want to believe something the more careful you have to be about assessing the evidence. “Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence,” he often said, and he was right. This week, the evolutionary biologist and author Richard Dawkins announced he thinks “his” AI is conscious, based on a couple of days’ interaction with Anthropic’s Claude chatbot. Inevitably, someone – Matthew Sheffield at Flux – has called the story “The Claude Delusion”. Dawkins has some company; at The Register, Liam Proven reports an engineer’s similar belief, and at the Independent Holly…