Three things I forgot to say today at the National Academy of Sciences Workshop on Enhancing Scientific Integrity

Uri Simonsohn and I spoke here: This workshop will bring together researchers, journal editors, publishers, funders, and scientific association leaders to identify practical, forward-looking strategies for strengthening data integrity and transparency in the social and behavioral sciences. Participants will explore innovative tools and frameworks to detect and prevent errors, promote accountability, and reinforce public trust in research. Discussions will also consider how journals, institutions, and professional societies can adopt fair, sustainable practices that support scientific rigor while ensuring accessibility for researchers across many contexts and settings. I brought up some relevant points, including: 1. The science-reform movement as an awkward alliance between reformers (who anticipated that failed replications will cause people to move away from some bad published ideas) and status-quo people (who anticipated that successful replications would validate various…